Uniformly pigmented, low shrinking polyester molding compositions

ABSTRACT

There is disclosed thickened, low shrinkage polyester molding compositions having improved pigmentation. The improved pigmentation in thickenable polyester molding compositions containing a carboxylated vinyl ester polymer low profile additive is achieved either by incorporating a surfactant in the composition, by using as the low profile additive a vinyl acetate/maleic acid copolymer, or by a combination of the two methods.

The invention relates to a means for improving the uniformity of pigmentation in thickenable, low shrink polyester molding compositions.

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

A major advance in commercial polyester molding technology was the introduction several years ago of chemically thickened systems. Chemical thickening is always employed in sheet molding compounds ("SMC"), and is increasingly being used in bulk molding compounds ("BMC"). In such systems, an alkaline material such as magnesium oxide or magnesium hydroxide is added to the uncured polyester along with fillers, glass fiber, and other standard materials. The alkaline material interacts with residual acidity in the polyester to build viscosity. The thickened system is relatively tackfree and easy to handle, and the high viscosity carries the glass fiber reinforcement to the extremities of the mold during crosslinking of the system. Thus, the use of thickened systems has made a major contribution to the commercial expansion of polyester molding.

Another technical improvement that has made a significant contribution to commercial polyester molding technology is the use of low profile additives to reduce shrinkage during the curing reaction, and to thereby improve dimensional stability and surface smoothness. Low profile additives are thermoplastic polymers such as vinyl acetate polymers, polystyrene, acrylic polymers, and polycaprolactones. There are a number of theories that seek to explain the low profile or anti-shrinkage action of these polymers, but the one that seems to best explain the phenomenon is the following:

The low profile additive is at least partly soluble in the uncured polyester/styrene solution. As the polyester/styrene mixture crosslinks, the thermoplastic polymer becomes incompatible or less soluble and at least partly comes out of solution. This action causes a volume expansion that compensates for the shrinkage that occurs when the polyester/styrene mixture crosslinks.

When a low profile additive is employed in a thickened composition, the increase of viscosity that occurs can cause the low profile additive to separate, and thereby cause a tacky surface. This problem is usually most severe with the more reactive polyesters, i.e., those having lower molecular weight to double bond ratios. To combat this, carboxylic acid functionality is incorporated in the low profile additive. The thermoplastic polymer itself can then enter the thickening reaction, thereby ensuring that a tack-free surface will result.

However, while alleviating the tackiness problem the introduction of these carboxyls into the thermoplastic can present other difficulties if not properly understood. For the thermoplastics to function optimally as shrinkage control agents they must become incompatible with the crosslinked polyester structure. Therefore, if the polyester resin, carboxylated thermoplastic, and thickening agent structure are not carefully controlled and balanced, the chemical thickening agent can bond the thermoplastic into the thermoset system through the carboxyl groups. This will reduce the amount of thermoplastic-thermoset incompatibility, thus reducing, and in extreme cases, actually eliminating the shrinkage control.

Another property of these composites which can be notably effected by this thickening process is internal pigmentability. Because of the thermoplastic-thermoset incompatibility, low shrink, low profile SMC and BMC is more difficult to uniformly pigment than conventional SMC and BMC. By careful formulation, and with the use of certain pigments, it is possible to balance adequate shrinkage control and dimensional stability with internal pigmentation in thickened polyester composites using commercially available carboxylated polycaprolactone low profile additive. However, truly zero shrink thickened polyester composites have not yet been uniformly and reproducibly pigmented in commercial molds except when certain black pigments were used with carboxylated polycaprolactone low profile additive.

DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

The invention provides a means for improving the uniformity of pigmentation in internally pigmented, thickened polyester molding compositions. In one aspect, the invention provides a curable composition comprising:

(a) a polyester resin comprising the reaction product of an olefinically unsaturated dicarboxylic acid or anhydride and a polyol;

(b) an olefinically unsaturated monomer that is copolymerizable with said polyester resin;

(c) a thickening agent comprising an oxide or hydroxide of a metal of Group I, II, or III of the Periodic Table;

(d) a pigment;

(e) a carboxylated vinyl acetate polymer low profile additive; and

(f) a surface active compound.

In another aspect, the invention provides a curable composition comprising (a), (b), (c), and (d), as defined above, and (g) a low profile additive comprising a vinyl acetate/maleic acid copolymer.

The invention also provides the cured composites produced by curing the above-described curable compositions.

The polyesters that are employed in the invention are reaction products of a dicarboxylic acid or anhydride, with a polyhydric alcohol. The dicarboxylic acids or anhydrides that are employed to produce the polyester, either singly or in combination, must include those that contain olefin unsaturation, preferably wherein the olefin unsaturation is alpha, beta- to at least one of the carboxylic acid groups. Such acids include maleic acid or anhydride, fumeric acid, tetrahydrophthalic acid or anhydride, hexachloroendomethylene tetrahydrophthalic anhydride ("chlorendic anhydride"), Diels-Alder adducts of maleic acid or anhydride with compounds having conjugated olefinic unsaturation, such adducts being exemplified by bicyclo[2.2.1]hept-5-en3-2,3-dicarboxylic anhydride, methyl maleic acid, and itaconic acid. Maleic acid or anhydride and fumaric acid are the most widely used commercially.

In addition to the olefinically unsaturated acid or anhydride, saturated and/or aromatic dicarboxylic acids or anhydrides can also be employed in producing the polyester. Such acids include phthalic acid or anhydride, terephthalic acid, hexahydrophthalic acid or anhydride, adipic acid, isophthalic acid, and "dimer" acid (i.e., dimerized fatty acids).

A polyol is also employed to produce the polyester. Such polyols include ethylene glycol, diethylene glycol, dipropylene glycol, butylene glycols, neopentyl glycol, glycerol and 1,1,1-trimethylolpropane. As a rule, not more than about 20 mole percent of the polyol will be a triol, with the remainder being one or more diols.

As is known in the art, polyesters that are employed in thickened molding compositions must contain residual acidity in order to enter into the thickening reaction. The nature and production of the polyesters used in such applications are known in the art.

The polyester composition of the invention also contains a monomer that contains ethylenic unsaturation, and which is copolymerizable with the polyester. Styrene is the preferred monomer in commercial practice today, although others can be used. Such others include vinyl toluene, methyl methacrylate, chlorostyrene, and diallyl phthalate.

The said monomer is employed in the polyester composition for the purpose of dissolving the polyester (which is a solid at ambient temperatures, i.e., about 20°-25° C.) to ensure that the polyester composition is a fluid. Enough monomer is employed so that the thickness or viscosity of the fluid is such that the fluid can be processed conveniently. Excessive amounts of the monomer are normally to be avoided, because such excess can have an adverse effect on properties. For instance, too much of the monomer may tend to cause embrittlement of the cured polyester. Within these guidelines, effective proportions of the monomer are normally found within the range of from about 35 to about 70, and preferably 40 to 55, weight percent, based on weight of polyester plus monomer, plus low profile additive.

A thickening agent is also employed in the invention. Such materials are known in the art, and include the oxides and hydroxides of the metals of Groups I, II and III of the Periodic Table. Specific illustrative examples of thickening agents include magnesium oxide, calcium oxide, zinc oxide, barium oxide, potassium oxide, magnesium hydroxide, and others known to the art. Thickening agents are normally employed in proportions of from about 0.1 to about 6 weight percent, based upon weight of polyester resin, plus monomer, plug low profile additive.

Pigments are also employed in the invention. Illustrative examples include black iron oxide, titanium dioxide, carbon black, chrome yellow, phthalocyanine blue and green, ceramic black, chrome green, ultramarine blue, chrome-cobalt-alumina turquoise, cobalt aluminate (blue), brown iron oxide, ceramic yellow (antimony, titanium-chrome oxide), titanium pigments (yellow, buff), molydate (orange), chrome orange, manganese (violet), chrome-tin (pink), cadmium mercury (maroon, red, orange), and the like.

Pigments are employed in the invention in conventional proportions, e.g., from about 0.5 to about 10 weight percent, based upon weight of polyester resin plus monomer plus low profile additive.

The invention has shown improvement in pigmentability with all pigments thus far tested.

In one aspect, the invention employs a carboxylated vinyl acetate polymer low profile additive. Such polymers include copolymers of vinyl acetate and ethylenically unsaturated carboxylic acids such as acrylic acid, methacrylic acid, maleic acid, fumaric acid, itaconic acid, and the like; vinyl acetate/vinyl chloride/maleic acid terpolymer, and the like. Reference is made to Comstock et al., U.S. Pat. No. 3,718,714 and Comstock et al. British Pat. No. 1,361,841, for descriptions of carboxylated vinyl acetate polymer low profile additives.

The useful carboxylated vinyl acetate polymer low profile additives ordinarily have molecular weights within the range of from about 10,000 to about 250,000, and preferably from about 25,000 to about 175,000. They are usually employed in proportions of from about 6 to 20, and preferably from about 9 to 16, weight percent, based on weight of polyester plus low profile additive, plus monomer.

As a general rule, the solution polymerized carboxylated vinyl acetate polymers are preferred in commercial practice because of their better batch-to-batch uniformity.

The polyester molding composition may also contain one or more of the known types of conventional additives, which are employed for their known purposes in the usual amounts. The following are illustrative of such additives:

1. Polymerization initiators such as t-butyl hydroperoxide, t-butyl perbenzoate, benzoyl peroxide, cumene hydroperoxide, methyl ethyl ketone peroxide, and others known to the art. The polymerization initiator is employed in a catalytically effective amount, such as from about 0.3 to about 2 to 3 weight percent, based on the weight of polyester plus monomer plus low profile additive;

2. Fillers such as clay, hydrated alumina, silica, calcium carbonate and others known to the art;

3. Reinforcing fillers such as glass fibers or fabrics, asbestos fibers or fabrics, various organic fibers or fabrics such as those made of polypropylene, acrylonitrile/vinyl chloride copolymer, and others known to the art; and

4. Mold release agents or lubricants, such as zinc stearate, calcium stearate, and others known to the art.

The polyester molding compositions of the invention can be cured under conditions similar to those used for known polyester compositions. Typical curing conditions are a temperature of from about 200° to 350° F. for 1 to 4 minutes at a pressure of 300 to 2000 psi.

In combination with the carboxylated vinyl acetate polymer low profile additives, the invention employs a surface active compound. A wide variety of surface active compounds can be employed. As a general rule, the ionic surface active compounds have given the best results. Classes of surfactants that deserve particular mention include:

Alkali metal, alkaline earth metal, and ammonium sulfonates;

certain ethylene oxide adducts of long chain (e.g., C₉ -C₁₈) aliphatic alcohols;

certain polyoxyethylene-polyoxypropylene block copolymers;

polyglycerol oleate;

ethoxylated sorbitan monooleate;

sodium 2-caprylic-1(ethyl beta oxipropanoic acid)imidazoline;

ethoxylated alkylguanidine amine complex;

sodium and methyl-N-long chain aliphatic taurate;

sodium isethionate coconut ester;

certain ethoxylated long chain alkylphenols;

N-long chain aliphatic quaternary ammonium halide;

Ethoxylated N-long chain aliphatic alcohol quaternary ammonium halide; and

Polydimethylsiloxane oil and certain other silicones.

The surfactant is employed in the invention in effective amounts, usually in the range of from about 0.1 to about 8 weight percent, based on weight and polyester plus low profile additive plus monomer.

The Examples below discuss in more detail the nature and proportion of the surfactants that are used in the invention.

In an alternative aspect of the invention, the low profile additive employed is a vinyl acetate/maleic acid copolymer. (The maleic acid can be replaced by the equivalent fumaric acid or maleic anhydride.) The maleic acid is used in the copolymer in conventional amounts, e.g., in amounts sufficient to provide about 0.1 to about 3 weight percent carboxyl groups, based on weight of copolymer. The molecular weight of the copolymer, and the amounts in which it is used, are conventional for carboxylated vinyl acetate low profile additives. The copolymer is used either with or without surfactant; although its use with a surfactant is preferred in most cases.

Experimental

In the Examples below, the following materials were used;

Polyesters

Polyester A--made from isophthalic acid, maleic anhydride, propylene glycol, and dipropylene glycol in approximate molar proportions of 0.3:0.7:0.8:0.2, respectively;

Polyester B--made from isophthalic acid, maleic anhydride, and propylene glycol in approximate molar proportions of 0.3:0.7:1.0, respectively;

Polyester C--made from maleic anhydride and propylene glycol in molar proportions of 1:1.1; and

Polyester D--made from isophthalic acid, maleic anhydride, and propylene glycol, in approximate molar proportions of 1.0:3,0:4.4, respectively.

The above polyesters are further characterized as follows:

                  TABLE I                                                          ______________________________________                                                            Weight %  Molecular                                                Acid        Solids in Weight to                                         Polyester                                                                             Number      Styrene   Double Bond Ratio                                 ______________________________________                                         A      16.4        72.4      286.7                                             B      --          --        244.4                                             C      28.5        65.5      156.1                                             D      19.9        65.4      224.7                                             ______________________________________                                    

Miscellaneous Additives

"Camel Wite"--Finely divided calcium carbonate used commercially as a filler in polyesters;

Zinc Stearate--used as a mold release agent;

t-Butyl perbenzoate--a peroxide initiator;

p-Benzoquinone--a polymerization inhibitor;

"RS-5988"--a 33 weight percent dispersion of magnesium oxide in a polypropylene maleate polyester;

"Marino H"--Magnesium hydroxide;

"Modifier M"--a 33 weight percent dispersion of magnesium oxide in a polypropylene maleate polyester;

"JM-308A" glass fibers--1/4-inch chopped glass fibers, of medium hardness;

"PPG-303" glass fibers--1/4-inch chopped glass fibers of medium harness, but a bit softer than JM-308A; and

Alumina trihydrate--a flame retardant filler.

Low Profile Additives

LP-A--40 weight percent solids solution of a 99.2/0.8 (by weight) vinyl acetate/acrylic acid copolymer in styrene, having the following properties:

Solution Viscosity 4000-6000 centipoises at 25° C.

Copolymer Inherent viscosity 0.48; 16-17 Ford cup

M_(N) 42,000

M_(W) 92,000

LP-B--40 weight percent solids solution of vinyl acetate/maleic acid copolymer in styrene. Different versions contained from 0.7 to 2.1 weight percent maleic acid in the copolymer, the remainder being vinyl acetate. The styrene solution viscosities varied from about 3400 to about 16,000 centiposes at 25° C. The Ford Cup viscosities of the copolymer varied from 12.4 to 17.8;

LP-C--35 weight percent solution of polystyrene in styrene, having a solution viscosity of 5000 cps at 25° C.; and

LP-D--33 weight percent solution of a copolymer of methyl methacrylate, ethyl acrylate, and acrylic acid (weight ratio 85:12.5:2.5) in styrene.

Pigments

PDI-1416--A green pigment;

PDI-1600--An orange pigment;

CM-3308--A gray pigment;

CM-2015--a black pigment; and

CM-3131--A blue pigment.

(The pigments employed were all commercial materials marketed as dispersions in a low molecular weight polyester. The pigment weights indicated in the formulations below are all dispersion weights, and thus include the dispersing medium.)

Surfactants

The surfactants employed are described in the Examples below.

Evaluation

The evaluation of the pigmentation was done visually. Non-uniformity of pigmentation can be manifested in any of several ways, such as the presence of small spots on the sample, cloudiness, flow marks, waviness, lack of color depth, streaks, mottling, and other similar defects. In most cases, the various samples were compared with a control. (The control employed was usually a polyester molding composition containing thickener, pigment, LP-A low profile additive, and no surfactant.)

The invention provides a means for improvement over polyester compositions containing LP-A low profile additive. Even though perfectly uniform pigmentation is not always provided, in its preferred aspects, the invention provides the best combination of uniform pigmentation and shrinkage control that is presently available in thickened polyester molding compositions.

EXAMPLE 1

Bulk molding compounds were made from the following formulations:

                  TABLE I                                                          ______________________________________                                         Component    1       2         3     4                                         ______________________________________                                         Polyester D  60      60        60    60                                        LP-B.sup.(1) 35      35        --    --                                        LP-A         --      --        35    35                                        Styrene       5      2          5    2                                         Surfactant A.sup.(2)                                                                        --      6         --    6                                         Camel Wite   175     175       175   175                                       Zinc Stearate                                                                                3      3          3    3                                         PD1-1416     10.5    10.5      10.5  10.5                                      Modifier M.sup.(3)                                                                          0.53    0.7       2.5   2.5                                       t-butyl      1.0     1.0       1.0   1.0                                       perbenzoate                                                                    1/4 inch glass                                                                              20      20        20    20                                        fibers.sup.(4)                                                                 ______________________________________                                          .sup.(1) 40 weight per cent styrene solution of copolymer of 98.5 per cen      vinyl acetate and 1.5 per cent maleic acid, the solution having a              viscosity of 15,720 centipoises at 25° C.                               .sup.(2) Sodium salt of isododecylbenzene sulfonic acid ("Siponate DS10",      Alcolac Chemical Company), 50 weight percent solution in styrene.              .sup.(3) Less magnesium oxide is required with the formulation containing      LP.B than with the one containing LPA because the higher proportion of         carboxyl groups in LPB causes more viscosity buildup (i.e., thickening).       Run 2 uses slightly more than  Run 1 because of the effect of the              particular surfactant used. Run 4 was not similarly adjusted for presence      of surfactant because the overall proportion of magnesium oxide in Runs 3      and 4 was much higher than in Runs 1 and 2, and the effect of the surfa        ctant was therefore not sufficient to require adjustment.                      .sup.(4) Runs 1-4 were first made using PPG303 glass fibers, and were the      repeated using JM308A glass fibers.                                      

The general procedure for making bulk molding compounds that was used in this Example 1 and in many of the other Examples was the following:

General Procedure for Preparation of Bulk Molding Compound (BMC) Formulations

The liquid components (including the pigment dispersion) were weighed individually into a Hobart mixing pan placed on a Toledo balance. The t-Butyl perbenzoate was weighted into a vial and added to the contents of the pan and the pan was attached to a Model C-100 Hobart mixer (in a hood). The agitator was started at slow speed, then increased to medium speed to completely mix the liquids and pigment over a period of 3 to 5 minutes. The agitator was then stopped, and the zinc stearate (internal mold release agent) was added to the liquid from an ice cream carton. The Hobart mixer was restarted and the zinc stearate mixed with the liquid until it was completely wet-out. The Camel Wite (calcium carbonate filler)* was next added to the pan contents (agitator off) then mixed, using medium to high speed, until a consistent paste was obtained. The mixer was again stopped and the weighed amount of Modifier M was poured into the pan from a tared beaker. The Modifier M was mixed into the paste over a period of 2-3 minutes, the mixer was again stopped**, and 175 grams of the paste was removed from the pan (using a large spatula) and transferred to a wide-mouthed 4-ounce bottle. This paste sample was stored in the capped bottle at room temperature and the viscosity was measured periodically using a Model HBT Brookfield Viscometer on a Helipath Stand.

After removal of the paste sample, the chopped glass fibers were added slowly (from an ice cream carton) to the pan with the mixer running on low speed. The mixer was run for 30 seconds after all the glass was in the paste. This short time gave glass wet-out without glass degradation. The pan was then removed from the mixer and separate portions of the BMC mix of 650 grams each were removed using spatulas and transferred to aluminum foil lying on a balance pan (balance in the hood). The mix was tightly wrapped in the aluminum foil (to prevent loss of styrene via evaporation) and stored at room temperature until the viscosity of the retained paste sample reached a desired value. The mixes in this study usually reached this viscosity within 24 hours of their preparation.

The general procedure for molding the samples of BMC was the following:

General Procedure for Molding Panels

The equipment used for compression molding of panels from the glass reinforced unsaturated polyester molding mixes was a 75-ton, Queen's hydraulic press fitted with a 12×12 inch matched metal die mold (chromed surface). The dies were heated to 300° F., and the 650 gram portion of mix was removed from the foil and placed in the mold. The mold was quickly closed (without stops) to a pressure of 600 psi, and the panel was cured for 2 minutes at 600 psi/300° F. The mold was opened, the panel was quickly removed, and allowed to cool (in a hood) under weights (to avoid warpage).

(Where any significant departures were made from the indicated general procedures for preparation of the BMC and molded panel, they are stated in the text.

Panels were molded (at 500 psi) from the abovedescribed formulations, and were measured for shrinkage and were visually evaluated for uniformity of pigmentation. The results are shown below in Table II:

                                      TABLE II                                     __________________________________________________________________________                                               Izod Impact                                Low Profile  Molding Viscosity,                                                                       Shrinkage,   Strength-                            Glass Fiber                                                                          Additive                                                                              Surfactant                                                                           ×10.sup.-6, centipoises                                                            mils/inch                                                                            Pigmentation                                                                          ft-lbs/inch                          __________________________________________________________________________     JM-308A                                                                              LP-B   A      8.5      0.25  Good   6.1                                  JM-308A                                                                              LP-B   none  23.2      0.60  Fair   5.0                                  JM-308A                                                                              LP-A   A     14.4      0.30  Fair   5.0                                  JM-308A                                                                              LP-A   none  42.4      0.35  Poor   4.5                                  PPG-303                                                                              LP-B   A     7.5 and 34.8                                                                             0.3   Fair   3.9                                  PPG-303                                                                              LP-B   none  68.8      0.6   Fair-Poor                                                                             4.0                                  PPG-303                                                                              LP-A   A     19.2      0.2   Fair-Poor                                                                             3.0                                  PPG-303                                                                              LP-A   none  19.8 and 44.8                                                                            0.25  Poor   3.1                                  __________________________________________________________________________

Shrinkage is determined on these 12×12 inch panels by measuring the length of each of the four sides with a microcaliper, adding the four lengths together, substracting this sum from 48, and then dividing the difference by 48 to thereby obtain the total shrinkage in mils/inch.

EXAMPLE 2

A series of bulk molding compounds were made and molded into panels by the general procedures described in Example 1. The formulations, shrinkage, and results of evaluation for pigmentation are displayed in Table III. The LP-B low profile additive employed was the one described above in Example 1.

                  TABLE III                                                        ______________________________________                                                   Run No.                                                              Component   1       2       3     4    5                                       ______________________________________                                         Polyester A 60      --      60    --   --                                      Polyester B --      60      --    60   --                                      Polyester C --      --      --    --   60                                      LP-B        30      30      30    30   30                                      Styrene     10      10      10    10   10                                      Camel Wite   200     200     200   200  200                                    Pigment (CM-2015)                                                                          12      12      12    12   12                                      Zinc Stearate                                                                               4       4       4     4    4                                      t-Butyl     1.1     1.1     1.1   1.1  1.1                                     perbenzoate                                                                    MgO         0.6     0.6     --    --   --                                      Mg(OH).sub.2                                                                               --      --      2.0   2.0  2.0                                     Glass (PPG-303)                                                                            15      15      15    15   15                                      Shrinkage, mils/inch                                                                       3.5     1.9     2.7   0.9  0.7                                     Pigmentation                                                                               Good    Good    Good  Fair Fair-Poor                                                                      (clouds)                                ______________________________________                                    

Control 1

A series of bulk molding compounds were made and then molded by the general procedures described in Example 1 from the formulations displayed in Table IV:

                  TABLE IV                                                         ______________________________________                                                      Run No.                                                           Component      1       2         3    4                                        ______________________________________                                         Polyester D    750     750       --   --                                       Polyester C    --      --        360  360                                      Styrene        125      73       30   --                                       LP-A           375     --        210  --                                       LP-C           --      420       --   240                                      Camel Wite     2500    2500      900  900                                      t-Butyl perbenzoate                                                                            13      13        9    9                                       Zinc Stearate   40      40       24    24                                      Modifier M (MgO)                                                                               30      38       18    18                                      Glass (PPG-303)                                                                               671     671       250  250                                      CM-2015 Pigment                                                                               148     148       --   --                                       CM-2020 Pigment                                                                               --      --        50    50                                      ______________________________________                                    

The panels were measured for shrinkage and were evaluated visually for pigmentation, which was judged on the depth of color, uniformity, and presence of mottling. The results are displayed in Table V:

                  TABLE V                                                          ______________________________________                                                        Low Profile Shrinkage                                           Run   Polyester                                                                               Additive    mils/inch                                                                              Pigmentation                                ______________________________________                                         1     D        A           0.27    Fair                                        2     D        C           2.00    Good                                        3     C        A           0.48    Poor                                        4     C        C           2.3     Fair to Good                                ______________________________________                                    

EXAMPLE 3

A series of bulk mold compositions were made using the general procedure described in Example 1. The basic formulation is shown below in Table VI:

                  TABLE VI                                                         ______________________________________                                         Component        Parts, by weight                                              ______________________________________                                         Polyester D      210                                                           Low Profile Additive                                                                            varied                                                        Surfactant A     varied                                                        Styrene          varied                                                        Camel Wite       525                                                           Alumina Trihydrate                                                                              175                                                           Zinc Stearate     14                                                           Pigment          varied                                                        t-Butyl perbenzoate                                                                             4.2                                                           p-Benzoquinone   0.1                                                           MgO              varied                                                        Glass (JM-308A)-to 20%                                                                          234-238                                                       ______________________________________                                    

The variable parts of the formulations are displayed below in Table VII. The LP-B employed was the one described in Example 1.

                                      TABLE VII                                    __________________________________________________________________________                RUN NO.                                                             Component  1   2  3   4   5   6   7  8 9 10                                                                               11                                  __________________________________________________________________________     LP-A       122.5                                                                              -- --  --  --  --  122.5                                                                             --                                                                               70                                                                               --                                                                               70                                  LP-B       --  122.5                                                                             122.5                                                                              122.5                                                                              122.5                                                                              122.5                                                                              -- 70                                                                               --                                                                               70                                                                               --                                  LP-C       --  -- --  --  --  --  -- 80                                                                               80                                                                               80                                                                               80                                  Styrene     6   6 17.5                                                                                6  12  17.5                                                                                6 --                                                                               --                                                                               --                                                                               --                                  Surfactant A                                                                              22  22 --  22  11  --  22 22                                                                               22                                                                               22                                                                               22                                  CM 3308    39  39 39  --  --  --  -- 39                                                                               39                                                                               --                                                                               --                                  CM 2015    --  -- --  44  44  44  44 --                                                                               --                                                                               --                                                                               --                                  PDI 1600   --  -- --  --  --  --  -- --                                                                               --                                                                               39                                                                               39                                  Modifier M 2.6 --  1.8                                                                               2.6 2.6  1.8                                                                                7 --                                                                               --                                                                               --                                                                               --                                  MgO powder (100%)                                                                         --   7 --  --  --  --  -- 4.2                                                                              4.9                                                                              4.9                                                                              7.5                                 __________________________________________________________________________

The BMC formulations described above were molded in a transfer mold using a 100-ton hydraulic press. 180-Gram charges were added to the ram, and a piston injected the BMC into the several mold cavities using a force of 800 pounds. There were five mold cavities in the transfer mold that were each connected to the ram by 126-millimeter (diameter) feed lines. The circular gates leading into the mold cavities had diameters of 64 millimeters. There were two rectangular cavities, each having dimensions of 5×1/2×1/2 inches, a 4-inch diameter by 1/8-inch circular cavity, a 2-inch by 1/8-inch circular cavity, and a 7×1/2×1/8-inch "dog bone" (tensile testing bar) cavity. The BMC was cured in the mold for 2 minutes at 300° F., and then discharged.

The molded specimens were evaluated as follows:

Shrinkage

The length of one of the nominally 5-inch bars from the same mold cavity were measured in all cases) was measured with micro-calipers. The shrinkage in mils (one mil=0.001 inch) is reported for each run.

Pigmentation

The large circular disk was examined for deepness of color, uniformity, and mottling. The best sample was rated "4", and the worst "1". The others were rated visually using these as standards. The results are displayed in Table VIII:

                  TABLE VIII                                                       ______________________________________                                         Run  Low Profile                                                                               Weight %   Shrinkage,                                          No.  Additive   Surfactant A                                                                              mils    Pigmentation                                ______________________________________                                         1    LP-B       3          12      4                                           2    LP-A       3          10      3                                           3    LP-B       --         10      3                                           4    LP-B       3          13      3                                           5    LP-B         1.5      10      2                                           6    LP-B       --         17      2                                           7    LP-A       3          12      1                                           8    LP-B + C   3          20      4                                           9    LP-A + C   3          19      3                                           10   LP-B + C   3          20      4                                           11   LP-A + C   3          19      2                                           ______________________________________                                    

EXAMPLE 4

A series of bulk molding compositions were made, and were then molded using the transfer mold described in Example 3. The several runs differed in the presence or absence of Surfactant A, the proportions (weight percent) of maleic acid in the copolymer of LP-B, and in the molecular weight (as evidenced by styrene solution viscosity) of the copolymer of LP-B. Two LP-A control runs were also included. The basic formulation used is shown below in Table IX:

LP-A control runs were also included. The basic formulation used is shown below in Table IX:

                  TABLE IX                                                         ______________________________________                                                          Parts, by weight                                              Component          Run 1   Runs 2-9                                            ______________________________________                                         Polyester D        630     210                                                 Low Profile Additive                                                                              408     122.5                                               Surfactant A        66     varied                                              Styrene             18     varied                                              Camel Wite         1575    525                                                 Aluminum trihydrate                                                                               525     175                                                 Zinc Stearate       42      14                                                 PDI-1416 Pigment   117      39                                                 t-Butyl Perbenzoate                                                                               12.6    4.2                                                 p-Benzoquinone      0.1    0.1                                                 Modifier M         16.5    varied                                              Glass (JM 308A)    808     235                                                 ______________________________________                                    

The variable parts of the formulation are shown below in Table X, along with the shrinkage, in mils. The best pigmentation was formed in Run No. 1, the worst in Run No. 9, with Runs 2-8 being intermediate between them in descending order. The fact that Run No. 5 was rated better than Run No. 7 appears at this time to be anomolous.

                                      TABLE X                                      __________________________________________________________________________                         % Acid in                                                       Low Profile                                                                           LP Viscosity                                                                           LP Additive                                                                           Parts of                                                                              Syrene,                                                                             Modifier                                                                            Shrinkage,                         Run No.                                                                             Additive                                                                              at 25° C., CPS.                                                                 Copolymer                                                                             Surfactant A                                                                          parts                                                                               M, parts                                                                            Mils                               __________________________________________________________________________     1    LP-B   3920     0.71  66      18  16.5 16                                 2    LP-B   3920     0.71  --      17.5                                                                               3.5  24                                 3    LP-B   6060    1.2    22      6   4.2  15                                 4    LP-B   8060    1.6    22      6   3.1  18                                 5    LP-B   14,840  1.4    --      17.5                                                                               1.8  16                                 6    LP-B   3400    1.1    22      6   4.2  14                                 7    LP-B   14,840  1.4    22      6   2.8  20                                 8    LP-A   5000    0.8    22      6   12   15                                 9    LP-A   5000    0.8    --      17.5                                                                                8   16                                 __________________________________________________________________________

EXAMPLE 5

A series of 12×12 inch panels were compression molded from BMC using the general procedures described above in Example 1. The several runs differed in the proportion of maleic acid in the copolymer of LP-B, and in the molecular weight of the copolymer of LP-B, as evidenced by styrene solution viscosity. No surfactant was used in this series. A control containing LP-A is included. The general formulation is shown below in Table XI:

                  TABLE XI                                                         ______________________________________                                         Component        Parts, by weight                                              ______________________________________                                         Polyester D      360                                                           Low Profile Additive                                                                            210                                                           Styrene           30                                                           Camel Wite       1050                                                          PDI 1416 Pigment  63                                                           Zinc Stearate     18                                                           Modifier M       varied                                                        t-Butyl Perbenzoate                                                                              6                                                            Glass (JM 308A)  391                                                           ______________________________________                                    

The variable parts of the formulation are displayed below in Table XII, along with the shrinkage, in mils/inch, measured as described above in Example 1. As was the case in Example 4, the Runs are arranged in the table in descending order of pigmentation rating.

                  TABLE XIII                                                       ______________________________________                                                       LP                                                                    Low      Viscosity                                                                               % acid  Modifier                                        Run  Profile  at 25° C.,                                                                       in LP   M,     Shrinkage,                               No.  Additive cps.     Copolymer                                                                              parts  mils/inch                                ______________________________________                                         1    LP-B     3400     1.1     7.0    0.42                                     2    LP-B     6060     1.2     3.4    0.52                                     3    LP-B     3480     1.7     4.0    0.00                                     4    LP-B     3970     1.4     3.8    0.42                                     5    LP-B     3920      0.71   6.0    0.33                                     6    LP-B     7540     1.5     3.0    0.65                                     7    LP-B     11,860   1.2     2.8    0.52                                     8    LP-A     5000     0.8     12     0.19                                     ______________________________________                                    

EXAMPLE 6 Surfactant Screening Studies

In this series of experiments, the following standard formulation was mixed in a 1/2-pint can, stirred with a Cowles dissolver (spinning propeller type), poured into a 3-inch (diameter) aluminum disk, and immediately cured for 15 minutes at 150° C. While the samples were all cast, not molded under pressure, the pigmentability evaluation correlates well with the results obtained for similar formulations in molded parts. While the thickener (MgO in this case) must be present in the samples, the mixture must be cured before the mixture has thickened or increased in viscosity. The probable reason for this is that, in the absence of pressure, there is insufficient flow in thickened mixtures to obtain homogeneous castings.

The standard formulation used in these screening experiments is shown in Table XIII:

                  TABLE XIII                                                       ______________________________________                                         Component        Parts, by weight                                              ______________________________________                                         Polyester D      30                                                            Low Profile Additive                                                                            17.5                                                          Styrene          2.5                                                           Camel Wite       87.5                                                          Zinc Stearate    1.5                                                           CM-2015 Pigment  5.3                                                           t-Butyl Perbenzoate                                                                             0.5                                                           Modifier M       varied                                                        Surfactant       varied                                                        ______________________________________                                    

After curing and removing from the aluminum dish, the cast parts were rated visually for depth of color, uniformity of pigmentation, presence or absence of small white specks, and mottling. The six formulations shown below in Table XIV were used as standards against which all the others were compared. The worst was given a rating of 1, the best 6, with the others being intermediate between them. The six standard formulations were the following (the LP-B employed in this Example was the one described in Example 1):

                  TABLE XIV                                                        ______________________________________                                                 Rating                                                                 Component 1       2       3     4     5    6                                   ______________________________________                                         LP-A      17.5    --      --    --    --   --                                  LP-B      --      17.5    17.5  17.5  --   17.5                                LP-C      --      --      --    --    17.5 --                                  Modifier M                                                                               1.25    1.25    0.75  0.75   0.5 0.75                                Surfactant A                                                                             3       --      3     6     --   --                                  Surfactant B.sup.(1)                                                                     --      --      --    --    --   3.6                                 ______________________________________                                          .sup.(1) 42 weight percent styrene solution of sodium salt of alphaolefin      sulfonate                                                                

In the surfactant screening series, the low profile additive employed was LP-B. Each surfactant was used in two proportions, 3 and 6 weight percent of active surfactant, based on weight of polyester, LP-B, plus styrene. Modifier M was used in amounts of 0.75 parts, by weight. Table XV, below, displays the chemical name of the surfactant, its Trade Name, its classification in McCutcheon's 1975 Edition of "Detergents & Emulsifiers", and the pigmentability ratings for the two proportions of surfactant used. In the table, "EO" represents ethylene oxide, "PO" represents propylene oxide, "NC" represents "did not cure", and the surfactants marked with an asterisk* were employed as a solution in styrene.

                  TABLE XV                                                         ______________________________________                                                               Pigmentability                                           Surfactant          Class   3%       6%                                        ______________________________________                                         "TERGITOL Min Foam 2x"                                                                             AT-28   2        1                                         EO/PO adduct of linear                                                         alcohol                                                                        "TERGITOL Min Foam 1x"                                                                             AT-28   1        1                                         EO/PO adduct of linear                                                         alcohol                                                                        "TERGITOL 15-S-3"   AT-28   1        2                                         EO adduct of linear alcohol                                                    "TERGITOL 15-S-5"   AT-28   3        1                                         EO adduct of linear alcohol                                                    "TERGITOL 15-S-9"   AT-28   1        3                                         EO adduct of linear alcohol                                                    "TERGITOL 15-S-15"* AT-28   2        2                                         EO adduct of linear alcohol                                                    "TERGITOL 15-S-30"* AT-28   2        1                                         EO adduct of linear alcohol                                                    "TERGITOL 15-S-50"  AT-28   1        2                                         EO adduct of linear alcohol                                                    "TERGITOL TMN-6"    AR-12   4        3                                         Trimethylnonyl poly(EO)                                                        ether                                                                          "TERGITOL TMN-10"   AR-12   4        3                                         Trimethylnonyl poly(EO)                                                        ether                                                                          "TERGITOL-08"       AP-10   4        NC                                        Na(2-ethyl-1-hexanol)                                                          Sulfate                                                                        "TERGITOL-4"        AP-12   3        1                                         Na(7-ethyl-2-methyl-4-                                                         undecanol) Sulfate                                                             "TERGITOL 15-S-7" EO                                                                               AT-28   1        NC                                        adduct of linear alcohol                                                       "Pluronic F-98"* EO/PO                                                                             AW-80   2        3                                         adduct of propylene glycol                                                     " Pluronic F-88"* EO/PO                                                                            AW-80   2        1                                         adduct of propylene glycol                                                     "Pluronic F-68"* EO/PO                                                                             AW-80   2        2                                         adduct of propylene glycol                                                     "Pluronic F-68LF"* EO/PO                                                                           AW-80   2        2                                         adduct of propylene glycol                                                     "TERGITOL XH"* EO adduct                                                                           AT-28   2        2                                         of linear alcohol                                                              "TERGITOL XJ" EO adduct                                                                            AT-28   2        2                                         of linear alcohol                                                              "TERGITOL 15-S-40"* EO                                                                             AT-28   2        2                                         adduct of linear alcohol                                                       "TERGITOL 15-S-12" EO                                                                              AT-28   2        1                                         adduct of linear aIcohol                                                       "Pluronic 3IR4" EO/PO                                                                              AW-82   2        1                                         adduct of ethylene glycol                                                      "Pluronic 31R1" EO/PO                                                                              AW-82   2        1                                         adduct of ethylene glycol                                                      "Pluronic 17R4" EO/PO                                                                              AW-82   3        2                                         adduct of ethylene glycol                                                      "Neodol 25-3" EO adduct                                                                            AT-28   1        1                                         of ethylen glycol                                                              Neodol 25-7" EO adduct of                                                                          AT-28   1        1                                         linear alcohol                                                                 "Neodol 25-12" EO adduct                                                                           AT-28   2        2                                         of linear alcohol                                                              "Neodol 25-3A" NH.sub.4 salt of                                                                    AQ-18   4        1                                         EO adduct of linear alcohol                                                    sulfate                                                                        "Neodol 25-3S" Na salt of                                                                          AQ-18   4        NC                                        EO adduct of linear alcohol                                                    sulfate                                                                        "Plurafac RA-43" EO/PO                                                                             AW-82   1        2                                         adduct of ethylene glycol                                                      "Plurafac RA-40" EO adduct                                                                         AT-28   1        1                                         of linear alcohol                                                              "Plurafac D-25" EO adduct                                                                          AT-28   2        2                                         of linear alcohol (Modified)                                                   "Ucane 11" Na alkylbenzene                                                                         AK-8    6        --                                        sulfonate                                                                      "Calsoft T-60"      B-13    6        6                                         triethanolamine dodecyl-                                                       benzene sulfonate                                                              Glyceryl monooleate AE-14   2        2                                         Glyceryl dioleate   AE-14   2        1                                         Glyceryl trioleate  AE-23   1        1                                         Polyglycerol oleate AE-14   3        2                                         "Tween 80" Sorbitan W-9     1        2                                         monooleate                                                                     "Tween 21" E0 adduct of                                                                            W-5     3        3                                         sorbitan monooleate                                                            "Abrosol 0" Diethanolamine-                                                                        A-28    2        2                                         oleic acid                                                                     condensate                                                                     "Brij 30" EO adduct of                                                                             BB-4    2        2                                         lauryl alcohol, 4 EO's                                                         Na propyl oleate sulfonate                                                                         AO-2    4        4                                         "Miranol MSA" Na 2-Caprylic-                                                                       BA-6    4        1                                         1- (Ethyl beta oxipropanoic                                                    acid) Imidazoline                                                              "Petronate K"       AI-6    2        1                                         Na petroleum sulfonate                                                         Na Xylene sulfonate AJ-18   4        3                                         "Tide" mixture of Na                                                                               BO      4        3                                         tallow alcohol sulfate and                                                     linear alkyl benzene sulfonate                                                 Na alpha-olefin sulfonate*                                                                         AG-1    6        5                                         Na alpha-olefin sulfonate                                                                          AG-1    2        1                                         (powder form)                                                                  "Centrolene-S" Lecithin                                                                            M-1     2        1                                         "Aerosol C-61"      bM      3        1                                         Ethoxylated alkylguanidine                                                     amine complex                                                                  "Igepon T-33" Na and                                                                               H-4     3        3                                         Methyl-N--oleyl taurate                                                        "Igepon TN-74" Na and                                                                              H-6     3        --                                        Methyl-N--palmitoyl taurate                                                    "Igepon AC-78"      I.12    4        3                                         Coconut ester, Na                                                              isethionate                                                                    "Aerosol OT-75" Dioctyl                                                                            I.12    4        3                                         Na isethionate                                                                 "Triton X-100" EO adduct of                                                                        AR-8    2        2                                         octylphenol                                                                    "Triton X-45" EO adduct of                                                                         AR-12   3        2                                         trimethylnonylphenol                                                           "Emulphor ON-877" EO adduct                                                                        AT-26   5        5                                         of fatty alcohol                                                               "Emulphor VN-430" EO adduct                                                                        AU-22   1        1                                         of fatty acid                                                                  "Emulphor EL-719" EO adduct                                                                        AU-24   2        2                                         of vegetable oil                                                               Polyethylene glycol 600                                                                            AW-6    2        2                                         monooleate                                                                     Polyethylene glycol 600                                                                            AW-8    2        2                                         dioleate                                                                       Polyethylene glycol 200                                                                            AW-42   1        2                                         monostearate                                                                   Polyethylene glycol 200                                                                            AW-48   2        1                                         distearate                                                                     "Arquad C-50"       D-17    3        5                                         Trimethyl cocoammonium                                                         chloride                                                                       Arquad S-50" Trimethyl                                                                             D-17    3        6                                         soyammonium chloride                                                           "Arquad T-50" Trimethyl                                                                            D-17    5        5                                         tallow-ammonium chloride                                                       "Ethoquad 0/12" Poly-                                                                              C-33    4        2                                         ethoxylated quaternary                                                         ammonium chloride-ethoxy-                                                      lated alkylol amide/amine-                                                     oleic                                                                          "Ethomeen T-12"     C-37    2        2                                         Bis(2-hydroxyethyl)tallow                                                      amine                                                                          "Ethodumeen T-20"   C-37    2        2                                         N,N'--polyoxyethylene(10)-N--                                                  tallow-1,3-diaminopropane                                                      "Nekal BA-77" Na alkyl                                                                             S-15    2        2                                         naphthalene sulfonate                                                          "Daxad 21" Monocalcium                                                                             AB-2    4        2                                         polymerized alkyl aryl                                                         sulfonic acid                                                                  "Byk-Mallinkrodt ST-80"                                                                            P-2     2        3                                         Silicone                                                                       "Byk-Mallinkrodt ST-60"                                                                            P-2     3        1                                         silicone                                                                       "Byk-Mallinkrodt FL-0"                                                                             P-2     3        3                                         Silicone                                                                       "Byk-Mallinkrodt FL-1"                                                                             P-2     3        3                                         Silicone                                                                       "Norlig 11 DA" Lignosulfonec                                                                       L-10    2        1                                         acid derivative                                                                "Marasperse N-22" Na ligno-                                                                        L-8     4        4                                         sulfonate                                                                      "Ultrawet DS" Na alkyl                                                                             AK-8    4        4                                         aryl sulfonate                                                                 "Sellogen HR-90" Na alkyl                                                                          S-15    4        1                                         naphthalene sulfonate                                                          "Conoco SA-597" dodecyl                                                                            AK-12   5        5                                         benzene sulfonic acid                                                          "Dowfax 2A1"        AL-8    4        4                                         Na dodecyl diphenyl                                                            ether disulfonate                                                              "Tamol SN" Na salt of con-                                                                         S-15    3        3                                         densed naphthalene sulfonate                                                   "Silicone L-76".sup.(1)                                                                            P       4        2                                         "Silicone Y-5900".sup.(1)                                                                          P       2        2                                         "Silicone L-45".sup.(1)                                                                            P-2     5        1                                         Polydimethylsiloxane                                                           "Silicone Y-6446".sup.(1)                                                                          P       4        1                                         "Silicone W-900".sup.(1)                                                                           P       4        2                                         "Silicone S-10".sup.(1)                                                                            P       2        1                                         "Silicone S-50".sup.(1)                                                                            P       1        1                                         "Silicone L-5420".sup.(1)                                                                          P-6     2        2                                         Siloxane-polyoxyalkylene                                                       Block copolymer                                                                "Silicone L-5303".sup.(1)                                                                          P-6     2        2                                         Siloxane-polyoxyalkylene                                                       Block Copolymer                                                                "Siponate DS-10"*   AK-8    3        4                                         Na dodecylbenzene sulfonate                                                    Dioctyl Na Sulfosuccinate                                                                          V-8     3        3                                         ______________________________________                                          .sup.(1) All silicones used in proportions of 0.3 and 0.6 percent.       

Those surfactants that are solids in the 100 percent active form should be dissolved in a solvent, preferably styrene, before being added to the mixture in order to ensure complete and uniform distribution throughout the mixture.

The following surfactants yielded a pigmentability rating of 3 or more, in at least one of the two concentrations employed, which means that they improved the pigmentability when compared with the same formulation containing no surfactant:

                                      TABLE XVI                                    __________________________________________________________________________     The following structure types with LP-B gave better color ratings than         the polyester plus                                                             LP-B and no surfactant                                                                                     Surfactant                                                                     Class                                              Structure Type  Trade Name  No.   Manufacturer                                 __________________________________________________________________________       Ethoxylated/Propoxylated                                                                     Ethoquad 0/12                                                                              C-33  Armak Co.                                      Amides/Amines                                                                  Amines and Quaternary                                                                        Arquad C-50;                                                                               D-17  Amrak Co.                                      Derivatives   s-50; T-SO                                                       Fatty Taurates                                                                               Igepone T-33                                                                               H-4   GAF                                                          Igepon TN-74                                                                               H-6   GAF                                            Isethionates  Igepon AC-78                                                                               I-12  GAF                                            Lignin Derivatives                                                                           Marasperse N-22                                                                            L-8   American Can Co.                               Silicone Derivatives                                                                         Byk-Mallinckrodt                                                                           P-2   Byk-Mallinckrodt                                             FL-0; FL-1                                                                     UCC L-45; L-76;                                                                            P-2   Union Carbide Corp.                                          W-900; Y-6446                                                    Succinate, Sulfo Derivatives                                                                 Aerosol OT-75                                                                              V-8   American Cyanamid                              Sorbitan Derivatives                                                                         Tween 21    W-5   ICI America                                    Naphthalene Sulfonates                                                                       Sellogen HR-90                                                                             S-15  Nopco Chemical Div.                                          Tamol SN    S-15  Rohm and Haas                                10.                                                                              Polymers      Daxad 21    AB-2  Dewey and Almy Chem. Co.                       Glycerol Fatty Esters                                                                        Polyglycerol                                                                               AE-14   --                                                         ester of oleic                                                                 acid                                                             Olefin Sulfonates (alpha)                                                                    alpha olefin                                                                               AG-1    --                                                         sulfonate                                                        Aryl Sulfonates                                                                              Sodium Xylene                                                                              AJ-18   --                                                         Sulfonate                                                        Diphenyl Sulfonates                                                                          Dowfax 2A1  AL-8  Dow Chemical Co.                               Fatty Acid (Oil) Sulfates                                                                    Sulfated propyl                                                                            AO-2    --                                           and Sulfonates                                                                               oleate, sodium salt                                              Alcohol Sulfates                                                                             Tergitol 08 AP-10 Union Carbide                                                Tergitol 4  AP-12 Union Carbide                                  Ethoxylated Alcohol                                                                          Neodol 25-3A                                                                               AQ-18 Shell                                          Sulfates and Sulfonates                                                                      Neodol 25-3S                                                                               AQ-18 Shell                                          Ethoyxlated Alkyl (Aryl)                                                                     Tergitol TMN-6;                                                                            AR-12 Union Carbide                                  Phenol Sulfates                                                                              TMN-10      AR-12 Rohm and Haas                                                Triton X-45                                                      Ethoxylated Alcohols                                                                         Emulphor ON-877                                                                            AT-26 GAF                                            (Propoxylated)                                                                               Tergitol 15-S-9;                                                                           AT-28 Union Carbide                                                15-S-5                                                         20.                                                                              Fatty Glycols and Pro-                                                                       Pluronic F-98                                                                              AW-80 BASF Wyandotte                                 poxylated Glycols                                                                            Pluronic 17R4                                                                              AW-82 BASF Wyandotte                                 Alkyl Aryl Sulfonates                                                                        UCANE 11    AK-8  Union Carbide                                                Ultrawet DS AK-8  ARCO Chemical                                                Siponate DS-10                                                                             AK-8  Alcolac, Inc.                                                Conoco SA-597                                                                              AK-12 Conoco Chemical Co.                                          Calsoft T-60                                                                               AK-16 Pilot Chemical Co.                             Amphoterics   Miranol MSA BA-6  Miranol Chem. Co.                              Cationic Surfactants                                                                         Aerosol C-61                                                                               BM    American Cyanamid                              (General)                                                                      Formulated/Blended                                                                           TIDE (mixture of                                                                           BO    Proctor and Gamble                             Compds. and Mixtures                                                                         tallow alcohol                                                                 sulfonate and linear                                                           alkyl benzene sulfonate)                                       __________________________________________________________________________

EXAMPLE 7

The procedure described in Example 6 was repeated, with the exception that the formulation employed LP-A as the low profile additive. Modifier M was employed in a proportion of 1.25 parts, by weight. Table XVII displays the Trade Name of the surfactant (all are identified above in Table XV), the surfactant class, the weight percent in which the surfactant was used, (based on weight of polyester plus low profile additive plus styrene), and the pigmentability rating, using as the pigmentability standards the six formulations described in Table XIV.

                  TABLE XVII                                                       ______________________________________                                                                         Pigment-                                       Surfactant    Class       %     ability                                        ______________________________________                                         "Arquad S-50" D-17        4.2   5                                              "Emulphor ON-877"                                                                            AT-26       4.3   1                                              Na alpha olefin sulfonate                                                                    AG-1        4.1   1                                              "Tween 80"    W-9         4.4   1                                              "Silicone L-45"                                                                              P-2         0.3   2                                              "Tergitol 08" AP-10       4.1   1                                              "Tergitol TM-10"                                                                             AR-12       4.4   2                                              "Daxad 21"    AB-2        4.4   5                                              Na Xylene Sulfonate                                                                          AJ-18       4.2   1                                              "Conoco SA-597"                                                                              AK-12       4.4   4                                              "Ethoquad 0/12"                                                                              C-33        4.3   4                                              "Marasperse N-22"                                                                            L-8         4.4   2                                              "Siponate DS-10"                                                                             AK-8        4.2   3                                              (Styrene solution)                                                             Control (no surfactant)                                                                      --          0     1                                              ______________________________________                                    

The following surfactants gave pigmentability ratings of 2 or more, which means that they improved the pigmentability compared with the formulation containing no surfactant:

                  TABLE XVIII                                                      ______________________________________                                                                Surf.                                                   Structure Type                                                                           Trade Name   Class No. Manufacturer                                  ______________________________________                                         1. Ethoxylated                                                                           Ethoquad     C-33      Armak Co.                                     Propoxylated                                                                             0/12                                                                 Amides/Amines                                                                  2. Amines and                                                                            Arquad S-50  D-17      Armak Co.                                     Quaternary                                                                     Derivatives                                                                    3. Lignin Marasperse   L-8       American                                      Derivatives                                                                              N-22                   Can Co.                                       4. Silicone                                                                              L-45         P         Union                                         Derivatives                      Carbide                                       5. Polymers                                                                              Daxad 21     AB-2      Dewey and                                                                      Almy Chem.                                    6. Alkyl Aryl                                                                            Siponate DS-10                                                                              AK.8      Alcolac, Inc.                                 Sulfonates                                                                               Conoco SA-597                                                                               AK.12     Conoco Chem.                                  7. Ethoxylated                                                                           TERGITOL     AR-12     Union                                         Alkyl (Aryl)                                                                             TMN-10                 Carbide                                       Phenol Sulfates                                                                ______________________________________                                    

Control Example 2

The surfactant screening experiments of Examples 6 and 7 were repeated, except that the low profile additive employed was the acrylic based LP-D. Modifier M was employed in a proportion of 1.25 parts, by weight. Table XIX displays the Trade Name of the surfactants, the surfactant class, the weight percent in which the surfactant was used, and the pigmentability rating.

                  TABLE XIX                                                        ______________________________________                                                                           Pigment-                                     Sufactant         Class     %     ability                                      ______________________________________                                         "Ethoquad 0/12"   C-33      4.3   2                                            "Daxad 21"        AB-2      4.4   3                                            "Marasperse N-22" L-8       4.4   2                                            "Arquad S-50"     D-17      4.2    4+                                          "Emulphor ON-877" AT-26     4.3   3                                            "Siponate DS-10"  AK-8      4.2   2                                            (Styrene solution)                                                             Control (no surfactant)                                                                          0         0      4+                                          ______________________________________                                    

None of the surfactants improved the control, and all but one gave a lower rating than the control.

EXAMPLE 8

The general procedure of Example 1 was employed to prepare 12×12 inch molded panels from the following formulations:

                  TABLE XX                                                         ______________________________________                                                        Run No.                                                         Component        (1)    (2)      (3)  (4)                                      ______________________________________                                         Polyester D      300    300      300  300                                      LP-A             150    --       --   --                                       LP-C             --     172      --   --                                       LP-B             --     --       150  --                                       LP-D             --     --       --   180                                      Styrene           50     28       50   20                                      Camel Wite       875    875      875  875                                      Zinc Stearate     20     20       20   20                                      t-Butyl perbenzoate                                                                              5      5        5    5                                       CM-2015           42     42       42   42                                      Modifier M        15     15       10   10                                      Paste Sample     175    175      175  175                                      PPG-303 Glass (10%)                                                                             128    128      128  128                                      ______________________________________                                    

Visual panel evaluations for pigmentability consisted of comparing the finished panels for color depth (pigment), dispersion of pigment, glossiness, etc. The pigmentability ratings of these four systems containing different low profile additives were as follows:

    ______________________________________                                         Formulation No.   Pigmentability                                               ______________________________________                                         #2 (Containing LP-C)                                                                             Best                                                         #3 (Containing LP-B)                                                                             Less                                                         #4 (Containing LP-D)                                                                             Less                                                         #1 (Containing LP-A)                                                                             Worst                                                        ______________________________________                                    

EXAMPLE 9

The general procedure of Example 1 was employed to produce 12×12 inch molded panels from the following formulations:

                  TABLE XXI                                                        ______________________________________                                                    (1)   (2)    (3)     (4)  (5)  (6)                                  ______________________________________                                         Polyester D  300     300    300   300  300  300                                LP-A         150     150    150   150  150  150                                Styrene       50      50     50    50   50   50                                Camel Wite   875     875    875   875  875  875                                Zinc Stearate                                                                                20      20     20    20   20   20                                t-Butyl perbenzoate                                                                          5       5      5     5    5    5                                 CM-2015       42      42     42    42   42   42                                Modifier M    15      15     15    15   15   15                                TERGITOL TMN-10                                                                              23     --     --    --   --   --                                 Conoco SA-597                                                                               --       23    --    --   --   --                                 Daxad-21     --      --      23   --   --   --                                 Siponate DS-10                                                                              --      --     --     46  --   --                                 (50% sol'n. in                                                                 styrene)                                                                       Tween 80     --      --     --    --    23  --                                 Silicone L-45                                                                               --      --     --    --   --    2.3                               Paste Sample 175     175    175   175  175  175                                PPC-303 Glass (10%)                                                                         130     130    130   130  130  128                                ______________________________________                                    

The pigmentability ratings of these panels were as follows:

    ______________________________________                                         Formulation No.   Pigmentability                                               ______________________________________                                         #2 (Containing SA-597)                                                                           Best                                                         #4 (Containing DS-10)                                                                            Best                                                         #6 (Containing L-45)                                                                             Less                                                         (No surfactant control)                                                                          Less                                                         #3 (Containing Daxad-21)                                                                         Less                                                         #1 (Containing TMN-10)                                                                           Less                                                         #5 (Containing Tween 80)                                                                         Worst                                                        ______________________________________                                    

As a series, these panels are generally worse than those from the experiments containing LP-B, which follow in Example 10.

EXAMPLE 10

Using the general procedure of Example 1, 12×12 inch panels were prepared from the following formulations:

                  TABLE XXII                                                       ______________________________________                                                    (1)  (2)    (3)     (4)  (5)   (6)                                  ______________________________________                                         Polyester D  300    300    300   300  300   300                                LP-B         150    150    150   150  150   150                                Styrene       50     50     50    27   50    50                                Camel Wite   875    875    875   875  875   875                                Zinc Stearate                                                                                20     20     20    20   20    20                                t-Butyl perbenzoate                                                                          5      5      5     5    5     5                                 CM-2015       42     42     42    42   42    42                                Modifier M    10     10     10    10   10    10                                TERGITOL TMN-10                                                                              23    --     --    --   --    --                                 Conoco SA-597                                                                               --      23    --    --   --    --                                 Daxad-21     --     --      23   --   --    --                                 Siponate DS-10                                                                              --     --     --     46  --    --                                 Tween 80     --     --     --    --    23   --                                 Silicone L-45                                                                               --     --     --    --   --     2.3                               Paste Sample 175    175    175   175  175   175                                PPG-303 Glass (10%)                                                                         130    130    130   130  130   128                                ______________________________________                                    

The comparative pigmentability rating of the panels prepared from these formulations are as shown:

    ______________________________________                                                        Color                                                           Formulation No.                                                                               Depth    Comments                                               ______________________________________                                         #4 (Containing DS-10)                                                                         Best     (Darker than Example 9                                                         #4)                                                    #2 (Contsining SA-597)                                                                        (Darker than Example 9,                                                                 #2)                                                    (No surfactant, Control)                                                                      Control                                                         #3 (Containing Daxad-21)                                                                               (Surface quite nice,                                                           darker than Example 9                                                          #6)                                                    #6 (Containing L-45)                                                           #1 (Containing TMN-10)  (Surface quite nice,                                                           darker than Example 9                                                          #1)                                                    #5 (Containing Tween 80)                                                                      Worst    (Surface quite nice,                                                           darker than Example 9                                                          #5)                                                    ______________________________________                                    

EXAMPLE 11

Using the same procedure described in Example 9 and 10, 12×12 inch molded panels were made using the carboxylated acrylic low profile additive LP-D, and evaluating the same surfactants as in Examples 9 and 10. In this series, the control, which contained no surfactant, appeared better than all the panels containing surfactants. There was very little difference, if any, between the several panels which contained surfactants. 

What is claimed is:
 1. A curable molding composition containing:(a) a polyester resin that is suitable for use in molding and which comprises the reaction product of an olefinically unsaturated dicarboxylic acid or anhydride and a polyol; (b) an olefinically unsaturated monomer that is copolymerizable with said polyester resin; (c) a thickening agent comprising an oxide or hydroxide of a metal or Group I, II, or III of the Periodic Table; (d) a pigment; (e) a carboxylated vinyl acetate polymer low profile additive having a molecular weight within the range of from about 10,000 to about 250,000; and (f) a surface active compound that is employed in an amount sufficient to enhance the uniformity of the pigmentation of the cured composite produced from said curable molding composition.
 2. The curable molding composition of claim 1 wherein the olefinically unsaturated monomer is styrene.
 3. The curable molding composition of claim 2 wherein the thickening agent is magnesium oxide or magnesium hydroxide.
 4. The curable molding composition of claim 1 wherein the surface active compound is a member selected from the group consisting of:(a) a sulfonic acid or an alkali metal, alkaline earth metal, or ammonium salt thereof; (b) an ethylene oxide adduct of a long chain aliphatic alcohol; (c) a polyoxyethylene-polyoxypropylene block copolymer; (d) polyglycerol oleate; (e) ethoxylated sorbitan monooleate; (f) sodium 2-caprylic (ethyl beta oxipropanoic acid)imidazoline; (g) ethoxylated alkylguanidine amine complex; (h) sodium and methyl-N-long chain aliphatic taurate; (i) sodium isethionate coconut ester; (j) ethoxylated long chain alkylphenol; (k) N-long chain aliphatic quaternary ammonium halide; and (l) polydimethylsiloxane oil.
 5. The curable molding composition of claim 1 wherein the surface active compound is sodium dodecylbenzene sulfonate.
 6. The curable molding composition of claim 1 wherein the surface active compound is a sulfonic acid or an alkali metal, alkaline earth metal, or ammonium salt thereof.
 7. The curable molding composition of claim 5 wherein the carboxylated vinyl acetate polymer low profile additive is a vinyl acetate/maleic acid copolymer.
 8. The curable molding composition of claim 6 wherein the carboxylated vinyl acetate polymer low profile additive is a vinyl acetate/maleic acid copolymer.
 9. The curable molding composition of claim 7 wherein the olefinically unsaturated monomer is styrene and wherein the thickening agent is magnesium oxide or magnesium hydroxide.
 10. The curable molding composition of claim 8 wherein the olefinically unsaturated monomer is styrene and wherein the thickening agent is magnesium oxide or magnesium hydroxide.
 11. A curable molding composition containing:(a) a polyester resin that is suitable for use in molding and which comprises the reaction product of an olefinically unsaturated dicarboxylic acid or anhydride and a polyol; (b) an olefinically unsaturated monomer that is copolymerizable with said polyester resin; (c) a thickening agent comprising an oxide or hydroxide of a metal of Group I, II, or III of the Periodic Table; (d) a pigment; (e) a low profile additive consisting essentially of a vinyl acetate/maleic acid copolymer.
 12. The cured composite produced by curing the composition of claim
 1. 13. The cured composite produced by curing the composition of claim
 11. 14. A process for the preparation of a pigmented curable molding composition comprising effecting the mixture of a polyester resin that is suitable for use in molding and which comprises the reaction product of an olefinically unsaturated dicarboxylic acid or anhydride and a polyol, an olefinically unsaturated monomer that is copolymerizable with said polyester resin, a thickening agent comprising an oxide or hydroxide of a metal of Group I, II or III of the Periodic Table, a pigment, a carboxylated vinyl acetate polymer low profile additive having a molecular weight within the range of from about 10,000 to about 250,000, and a surface active compound that is employed in an amount sufficient to enhance the uniformity of the pigmentation of the cured composite produced from said curable molding composition.
 15. A process as claimed in claim 14 wherein the carboxylated vinyl acetate polymer low profile additive is a vinyl acetate/maleic acid copolymer.
 16. A process for making a pigmented molded article having a smooth surface which comprises molding at an elevated temperature a pigmented curable molding composition comprising a polyester resin that is suitable for use in molding and which comprises the reaction product of an olefinically unsaturated dicarboxylic acid or anhydride and a polyol, an olefinically unsaturated monomer that is copolymerizable with said polyester resin, a thickening agent comprising an oxide or hydroxide of a metal of Group I, II or III of the Periodic Table, a pigment, a carboxylated vinyl acetate polymer low profile additive having a molecular weight within the range of from about 10,000 to about 250,000, and a surface active compound that is employed in an amount sufficient to enhance the uniformity of the pigmentation of the cured composite produced from said curable molding composition.
 17. A process as claimed in claim 16 wherein the carboxylated vinyl acetate polymer low profile additive is a vinyl acetate/maleic acid copolymer.
 18. A pigmented molded article having a smooth surface prepared by the process of claim
 16. 19. A pigmented molded article having a smooth surface prepared by the process of claim
 17. 20. A process for the preparation of a pigmented curable molding composition comprising effecting the mixture of a polyester resin that is suitable for use in molding and which comprises the reaction product of an olefinically unsaturated dicarboxylic acid or anhydride and a polyol, an olefinically unsaturated monomer that is copolymerizable with said polyester resin, a thickening agent comprising an oxide or hydroxide of a metal of Group I, II or III of the Periodic Table, a pigment, and a low profile additive comprising a vinyl acetate/maleic acid copolymer.
 21. A process for making a pigmented molded article having a smooth surface which comprises molding at an elevated temperature a pigmented curable molding composition comprising a polyester resin that is suitable for use in molding and which comprises the reaction product of an olefinically unsaturated dicarboxylic acid or anhydride and a polyol, an olefinically unsaturated monomer that is copolymerizable with said polyester resin, a thickening agent comprising an oxide or hydroxide of a metal of Group I, II or III of the Periodic Table, a pigment, and a low profile additive comprising a vinyl acetate/maleic acid copolymer.
 22. A pigmented molded article having a smooth surface prepared by the process of claim
 21. 